A decision on Sterling’s full time replacement will be made in the off season. Hearing Craig Carton doing play by play in the Yankee radio booth on Saturday, Aug. 10, 2024 must mean someone realized that “doing play by play in the minors”
is irrelevant to having any job in the two-person Yankee radio booth.
In the case of choosing John Sterling’s replacement for play by play,
the person needs to be a natural talker, preferably someone who’s already succeeded in talk radio,
who’s thus going to be at ease participating in give and take in the
booth with analyst Suzyn Waldman. Further, he isn’t going to have a
fake, “chirpy” delivery during play by play as others do in an attempt
to compensate for the fact that they have no personality and no
confidence. With the exception of Craig Carton and Rickie Ricardo,
none of the others trying out for Sterling’s replacement belong on
radio at all. Craig sounds perfect w. Suzyn. What isn’t known is how much they’d be willing to pay Carton and what other job prospects he may have.
…………………………………….
Added: Decision on full time Sterling replacement to be made in off season:
7/15/24, “WFAN taps Craig Carton to call 3 Yankees games in August alongside Suzyn Waldman,” The Athletic, NYTimes.com
“A new but familiar voice will soon rejoin WFAN — and in a way he hasn’t been heard before.
The station will tap Craig Carton to work alongside Suzyn Waldman on three New York Yankees broadcasts next month, Carton announced on the station Monday alongside hosts Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber.
He’ll be on during the series at home against the Texas Rangers from Aug. 9 – 11. Carton said that the Yankees had called him directly about the gig.
“It’s a great honor,” he said. “It’s a great privilege.”
Carton left WFAN last summer to focus on his morning talk show with Fox Sports 1.
Carton said he won’t be over the top.
“I want to be clear about that,” he said. “I’m not going to do
something that’s clownish. I got to leave the crazy home run calls to
the memory of John and his greatness of all of the years. But I’ll do my
best. I’ll make sure that it’s unmistakably me and it’s just awesome.”
He added that he hopes he brings the Yankees a bit of luck. The team
has struggled of late, going 8-18 over its last 26 games. It lost its
final game of the first half Sunday in brutal fashion, getting walked off by the Baltimore Orioles after
committing a pair of errors. Still, the Yankees are just a game behind
the O’s for first place in the American League East.
“All they really need is a little positive juju,” Carton said. “Like a good luck charm, if you will. The (New York) Mets had
the rally pimp in April. They had Grimace in June. They had some fat
guy dancing to ABBA, I think, now. That has worked for them.”
A week ago, the New York State Broadcasters Association announced that Carton would be inducted into its Hall of Fame this year. Waldman has been working with a rotation of play-by-players since
John Sterling retired in April. Sterling had been calling Yankees games
for 36 years. He had paired with Waldman for 20 seasons.
As for whether Carton would ever consider being the Yankees’ radio play-by-play man full-time, it didn’t sound like much of an option.
“There’s got to be a lot of zeros in that check,” he said.
Carton added he’s not sure exactly how far he’ll go if he feels the need to criticize the team while calling the games.
“Here’s the real question,” he said. “At some point, if you see something like Giancarlo Stanton walking to second base, you might have to be critical. I’m wondering, does my phone ring on the way home from the Yankees?”
Since Sterling’s retirement,
Waldman has worked games with Justin Shackil, Emmanuel Berbari, Rickie
Ricardo and Brendan Burke. The expectation is that WFAN will use the
rest of the season to try out different play-by-players and
make their decision on a full-time replacement in the offseason.
“I am a very blessed human being,” Sterling said in a statement at the time.
“I have been able to do what I wanted, broadcasting for 64 years. As a
little boy growing up in New York as a Yankees fan, I was able to
broadcast the Yankees for 36 years. It’s all to my benefit, and I leave
very, very happy. I look forward to seeing everyone again on Saturday.””
..........................................
Added: For Yankee Radio Booth fans only, written in Oct. 2011:
Oct. 15, 2011, "John Sterling, Suzyn Waldman, and the Yankee Radio booth," by Susan
John Sterling has called every Yankee post season game from 1995 to the present along with 162 regular season games from 1989. He has seen most if not every pitch thrown in regular and post season for 23 years. A recent NY Times article quotes Michael Kay saying Sterling does 162 games a year and that seems like a lot to Kay who does about 125.
While stating he's done about 3800 games the article doesn't make clear
that Sterling has done 156 post season games. No one else has done
that. TV doesn't do that.
- Yankee radio and its voices have provided continuity for fans
through entire seasons, Sterling since 1989 and through post seasons
starting in 1995 and Sterling and Waldman since 2005.
Unhappy with Yankee stadium attendance in the mid and late 1990's Yankee ownership said "
nobody would come to the Bronx," and wanted to move the
stadium to Manhattan (parag. 6) (cit. #4). Suzyn Waldman
remembers this, because she's been covering the Yankees since the
late 1980's first as a radio beat reporter, later as an analyst, and since
the mid '90's on television in varous capacities, and has been Sterling's partner on radio since 2005. In
1996 the Yankees were 7th in AL attendance. In
1998 they ranked 8th in attendance through August
(parag. 18).
They didn't get to #1 in AL attendance until 2003. These
facts don't usually come up in conversation and don't fit the
narrative that the Yankees always have more attendance, more money, and
are just luckier. As a fan it's preferable to listen to someone who
has experienced all this and who will fill in important details others
may leave out.
21
of those 156 post season games went into extra innings. Sterling did
share play by play with partners until he began doing all innings in
2005 but he called the majority and likely was watching most of the
rest. Now that the Yankees are successful and have a
somewhat porous front office with out of town owners (
context below,
citation
7), the Yankee radio booth is prime for exploitation. Whether by a
celebrity-seeker or for what some perceive as the pot of gold, the
glittering financial opportunities of
shaping public opinion.
- "Then the best quote of all:
"Yankees fans who like him are people who just want someone to root for the team," (Phil) Mushnick said.
- Or is more boring than geometry?
And it's not like Sterling and Waldman never criticize
the Yankees. They do it often. (Just wait till they fail to advance a
runner)....
It's OK to enhance the product with some personality, you know.
As if being a Yankee fan is controversial or worse, the Times quotes a fan saying some people think the team should have a
'network level' play by play
announcer--implying someone who wasn't a Yankee fan. (So it doesn't
matter what you give Yankee fans they'll always be there, besides we
want a Bud Selig/ESPN robot in there who'll talk up what a great idea it
would be to let the best Yankee pitchers all go and pitch in the next
World Baseball Classic because it would show the Yankees are
'unselfish'--might be the thought process). The article does state
Sterling freely rips the team when they do something wrong just like the
average fan. The word 'homer'
doesn't remotely apply to Sterling if it means only saying good things.
- 'Not being a Yankee fan' means something different than not being a fan of most other teams.
There is often
deep bitterness whether conscious or not. Perhaps due in part to
24/7 anti Yankee negativity
(parag. 3). The Yankee fan experience, images of its players and the
like are easy to destroy because a lot of people want to and no one is
really looking out for them.
Attack squads
are usually at the ready to diminish the Yankee fan experience. No one
tries to stop them when they get on a roll-not even in the
interest of common decency.
Apparently lead to believe they don't deserve to be a fan as much as
anyone else, some fans retreat at such times, passively thinking oh
well, it's part of the territory with the Yankees.
One NY tabloid whose owner made his fortune via
his company Boston Properties has shown a fixation
with Roger Clemens. Perhaps some people will never get
over Clemens. The publisher
adores dictator Fidel Castro,
and both are baseball fans.
This person has been allowed to insert one of his employees inside the
Yankee Radio booth during play by play every 5th inning for several
years. It's a paid sponsorship capitalizing on the Yankee name and the
implied endorsement of John, Suzyn, and the Yankees to advance the
advertiser's particular baseball agenda. The goal of any advertiser in
any medium is to sell something, to influence public opinion. No amount
of money makes this an editorially sound idea for the Yankees. I've
never heard a booth guest who could provide more than Suzyn's peerless
reporting though she and John are generous and welcoming to 'guests'
and create an environment in which the guest can appear to be adding
something. The main individual selected by the tabloid owner to
represent him in the Yankee radio booth the past few years
is not a Yankee fan.
This was not news to me having seen this person's version of events
when he was on Bud Selig's copywriting staff at MLB.com a few years ago.
That this
individual given a half inning
inside the Yankee radio booth about 5 days out of seven is not a
Yankee fan was great news to a professional Yankee hater. As the Yankee
hater said, "
After all, if you ain’t with ‘em, you’re usually against ‘em!"
- The fan experience of the Yankee Radio booth is on hold until
the tabloid reporter leaves. Suzyn and John are such pros at smoothing
things over a casual listener might not realize something unpleasant
and even disrespectful just happened.
I trust both Suzyn and John to give the
good and the bad
but always from a perspective of someone who cares about the team. Not
someone who's trying to be smarter or make a name for themselves or
get on ESPN.
Being 'a homer' to NY credentialed media doesn't mean voting for a Yankee in post season awards. It can mean helping the Yankee front office
to smear favorite players in
the media. Yankee suits can certainly request radio broadcasters cover
player issues one way or another. Why wouldn't they since it's well
known they do it in other media? I haven't heard Suzyn or John say
they've been told to say one thing or another of course. Neither would
do that. As a listener with particular interest on this topic, I've
heard a few instances that sounded influenced from outside the radio
booth. There is one person most likely to be giving editorial orders to
Yankee radio and if you're reading this you probably know who it is.
The few instances I refer to were 'high value' issues. Once or twice
I've had to turn the radio off for awhile after one of these events.
- Widespread bias against the Yankees or anyone is stealing.
Stealing from players, the team, their life work and lastly it steals
from fans.
Others can have a fan experience
but Yankee fans can't,
is the idea. I need to know the voices in the radio booth know what we
as fans are up against everywhere in the outside world. John and Suzyn
have been the antidote. They have endless knowledge and they know the
big picture and I hope they both stay as long as they wish. What is
waiting to replace the gracious environment they have created are
shrill, formulaic bores. Sterling is a natural talker which is one of
the reasons he's good at play by play. Many of those I hear doing play
by play are not natural talkers or great personalities. They rely on
formulas to get them through. The ear splitting high decibel chirpy,
sing-song affectation is common, for example with Mets radio guys. The
technique is to end a phrase on a low register, then pick up the next
phrase 2 or 3 octaves higher, splitting the average ear drum.
- This is a violation of the first law of radio, which is that
it's a one to one medium, one person talking to one other person. Or
allowing us to listen in on a one on one conversation.
With
many of today's baseball radio talkers it's sounds more like a puppet
show. Perhaps it's intended to make the game sound more exciting. ESPN's
Dan Shulman uses another device, an affectation of the voice rising,
rising in crescendo to thunderous level at inappropriate times. I'm
thinking he's about to tell me something big and it ends up being
nothing, like a routine catch of a ball in the outfield and a normal
throw to first base with no big effect either way on the game.
One team's booth has a schtick where they try not to allow a second to
go by without the other guy filling it up with unnecessary words. Fans
thereby aren't allowed moments to hear the stadium presence. This
shows a lack of confidence in an announcer's ability to do spontaneous
give and take in a booth. John and Suzyn aren't like that, they talk in
normal, conversational tones (with the occasional exception of a home
run call which other guys do as well but none with famous tags attached
to players that become known around the world, '
don't-cha know.') Sterling's voice allows one to relax and enjoy the game.
- Joe Castiglione is one of few others out there who seems like a
natural talker where you're not always worried he's going to trip over
himself.
As noted in the
NY Times article,
Sterling has never missed a game. I was quite surprised to learn from
the article that he only makes $375,000+ in salary. I would have
thought around $1 million. Regarding Phil Mushnick's remarks about him I
see no reality whatsoever. As far as occasional mistakes, I've
listened to other guys and they all make them. In Sterling's case,
Waldman usually corrects what needs to be corrected and she does it
graciously.
- The Yankee TV side, the YES Network, is like a junior ESPN.
It's run by a
conglomeration of interests with the
Yankees owning a reported 35%. The majority is owned by
Goldman Sachs and
hedge fund people who it's said
"want a partnership with the Yankees about how the games are broadcast.'' For
years YES Network Yankee studio shows (pre and post game) have
promoted a non-Yankee player who is also a Bud Selig and ESPN favorite.
YES promoted the non-Yankee player's record for a regular season stat
when they mentioned Mariano Rivera's name which
certainly helped the image of the non-Yankee player. The same player received similar free promotion on Yankee radio this year.
- I hope both John and Suzyn remain on Yankee radio as long as
they want. If something different happens, I probably won't be
listening.
=====================
- Citation 1, NY Times article on Sterling, 10/1/11
10/1/11, "
Voice of Yankees Draws High Ratings and Many Critics," NY Times, Bill Pennington
---------------------
- Citation 2, a total of 4 items on spreading a culture of negativity around the Yankees:
Two items from Joel Sherman, first from his
2006 book on the 1996 Yankees, second from one of his NY Post articles; followed by an item
from MLB Network 7/31/10, followed by a
Bud Selig statement on WFAN, 10/5/06
- Joel Sherman finds the Commissioner's office to be the source of much anti Yankee negativity. From his 2006 book about the 1996 Yankees, "Birth of a Dynasty," p. 311:
"
Unfortunately for the legacy of this group, the success of these Yankees (1996 team) coincided with - a powerful push by central baseball to convince fans
that the disparity between the financial "haves" and "have-nots"
was destroying the competitive balance of the sport. The Yankees
came to embody the big-market superpowers. They were demonized for buying championships.
They were cast as villains by a Commissioner's Office
that saw the advantages of portraying them as a prop in a strategy
to win salary concessions from the players in collective bargaining, - Thus the Yankees of this era do not receive near the amount of credit they deserve for what they accomplished."...
Page 311 from Joel Sherman in his 2006 book, "Birth of a Dynasty," about the 1996 Yankees.
The Yankee organization has failed to address this problem as
baseball media has become even more centralized under Bud Selig. It
wouldn't take much effort and it could make a big difference. Negativity
is used because it works. On the other hand, it seems 'the Yankees'
(whoever that is) view the
media as a tool to smear their own players.
From Joel Sherman's column, 9/21/07: "
As a rival executive (of the Yankees) said recently,
- “...It is staggering the amount of negative noise that comes in New York (from media and fans)
when your team spends that much money, has their expectations and
has their history. It is bad anywhere, but in New York it is so much
louder and so much more relentless. To stay the course, to stay
yourself, I really admire that.”"
From Joel Sherman's
NY Post column, 9/21/07, "Steadiness and Sturdiness"
- ----------
- MLB Network host compares Yankees to dictators abusing human rights:
7/31/10, "
Yankee deadline moves trample others as if they were third world victims"
MLB Network TV anchor's response to what the
Yankees did at the trading deadline noted by commenter to Yankee LoHud blog:
- 7/31/10, ""Betsy July 31st, 2010 at 4:52 pm
MLB Network's "Matt V. (Vasgersian) is really a freaking clown; he just said
the Yankees tramped over the other teams
from blog thread,
Park designated for assignment," 7/31 /10
- (This is the line Bud Selig wants MLB media people to beat into the ground. ed.)
4th item, 10/5/06,
Bud Selig on WFAN:
Chris Russo on WFAN:
Bud, I know you probably won't answer this but you must be happy the Yankees lost today, must be thrilled, because this helps your argument for parity.
Bud Selig answers: "
Well, you're right, Chris, I'm not going to answer that."
- ----------------------------
- Citation 3, two Mike Lupica articles:
12/5/2010, "Shame on Yankees for dropping ball and insulting Derek Jeter during heated contract talks,"
- Mike Lupica, NY Daily News
""They wanted it to look, in the more heated parts of this, as though Jeter was the greedy one. They were twitchy to get out there what they said Jeter wanted, that Jeter wanted $23 million or $24 million a year, whatever the Yankees said he was asking for. - Not just delighted. Thrilled.
They thought it made them look good. But you know who has always made them look good? Jeter has. Second Lupica article:
-------------------------------
- Citation 4, Yankee attendance in 1998, and "nobody will come to the Bronx" 9/28/1998:
"To (George) Steinbrenner's annoyance, the Yankees ranked - per home game through August (1998)."...
...
From Business Week article, "The Yankees: Steinbrenner's Money Machine," 9/28/1998, by Anthony Bianco with Mark Hyman in Baltimore5/03/2008,
"Nobody will come to the Bronx," Remember those days, asks Suzyn Waldman on Yankee Radio, XMMLbChat.blogspot.com
- ----------------------------
Citation 5, YES Network and Goldman Sachs items
8/3/2007, "
SPORTS BUSINESS; A Stake in the YES Network Is on the Market, but Not the Yankees' Share," NY Times, R. Sandomir
''It's a bit of a sideshow if the Yankees stay in or out, if they do or don't sell,'' (Gerald) Cardinale said.
Any new financial partners, he added, ''
will want a partnership with the Yankees about how the games are broadcast.''
8/2/2007, "
Goldman Sachs would consider YES Network sale for right offer," AP, USA Today
- "The Yankees formed YES in 2001 and launched the network the following year. Yankee Global Enterprises, the team's parent company, owns about 35 percent of the network, with the remainder controlled by Goldman and Providence Equity Partners, and an investment group headed by former New Jersey Nets owner Ray Chambers."
- ---------------------------
- #6, Suzyn Waldman citations
7/16/10, "
Yankees radio announcer Suzyn Waldman cultivated unique relationship with owner George Steinbrenner," Bob Raissman, NY Daily News
- "Right from the late 1980s when she landed in the world according to George M. Steinbrenner.
"I like my women to spend my money and look real pretty," Steinbrenner bellowed during their first face-to-face meeting in 1988. "I don't like them to be pilots, policemen or sports reporters."
Waldman
wrote that her 5:05 p.m. WFAN "Yankees Report" was heard by more
people than those who read all the metropolitan area newspapers
combined ("I should be taken seriously," she wrote). Her letter made
the rounds of the ladies in Steinbrenner's office. Waldman walked in a
hero, only to be greeted by Steinbrenner's chauvinistic babble....
That's how this relationship began. Early on, long before she became the Yankees radio analyst, he critiqued her work, canvassing his favorite Manhattan
saloon keepers and asking: "What do you think of that girl?" In times
of trouble, Steinbrenner was there. He became a coveted source,
providing the kind of access and info other reporters did not normally receive."...
--------------------------
- Citation #7, Yankee leadership, 2 Ken Davidoff articles
10/2/08, "
Cashman aims to win with dysfunctional Yankees," Newsday, Ken Davidoff (link inactive
but posted elsewhere)
""But in their quest to regain the mantle as baseball's elite team, they still face
a quandary that shows no sign of going away:
- From speaking to employees up and down the organizational food chain, you still get the sense that
Whereas
George Steinbrenner ruled all in his prime, obsessing over both $189-million agreements with
Derek Jeter and uncollected garbage on the practice field in Tampa, the
- 1. Hal Steinbrenner.
He has worked hard in the last year to establish a relationship with
Cashman and the baseball people, commuting to Yankee Stadium from his
Tampa home nearly every week. But he is human, unlike his dad, in that
he can't get his tentacles over everything.
- 2. Hank Steinbrenner.
The "advisory-board" comments -- there will be no advisory board,
Cashman confirmed Wednesday -- provide further proof that Hank is a
highly entertaining fraud. As long as he's got his last name, however,
Hank won't be ignored altogether.
- 3. Felix Lopez. The
husband of George Steinbrenner's younger daughter Jessica, Lopez has
exploited Hal's and Hank's limits to gain a surprising amount of power
over the Tampa-based operations. Lopez is known as such a bully and a
boor that he makes Hank Steinbrenner look
- like a gentleman and a scholar, in comparison.
- 4. Randy Levine. The
head of everything in New York, including the Yankees' role in YES
and the new Yankee Stadium, team president Levine used to be
predictable in that he would carry out George Steinbrenner's wishes.
Now, with The Boss largely resting in the background, Levine sits as
more of a wild card.
From this, you have people wondering who really runs things. It's a question that, in reality, probably will fade only if, or when,
So in the interim, the Yankees will put forward their best words."
from Ken Davidoff Newsday column, 10/2/08, "Cashman aims to win with
dysfunctional Yankees"-------------
5/16/11, "
Decision-Makers off-target again," Ken Davidoff, Newsday (Newsday is subscription)
Ailing reliever
Rafael Soriano said after the game that
George Steinbrenner's son-in-law,
Felix Lopez -- whose background is in gardening, not medicine -- advised him to take
- a couple of weeks off to rest his ailing elbow....
Tough, tough times for the Yankees. "This is where you're tested as a team," Girardi said.
Successful industries,
be they baseball, banking or bagels, place their personnel in a
position to succeed. And calibrate their expectations accordingly.
Both on and off the field Monday, the Yankees failed at that skill. They can blame only themselves for the intensifying storm surrounding them....
At 20-19, three games behind the Rays in the American League East, the Yankees feel like a team in crisis. Of course, most teams carry that aura when the results stink....
And what in the name of Thurman Munson was Yankees brass thinking when it interrupted Derek Jeter's day to discuss the comments he made Sunday about Jorge Posada's Saturday boycott?...
- Speaking of not being surprised, you could have set your watch to Jeter's comments on Sunday.
He defended his longtime friend and teammate while standing clear of Posada's feud with the Yankees' front office. - Of
course Posada received preferential treatment from the team captain.
Of course Jeter wouldn't have been so effusive had this been Alex Rodriguez or Nick Swisher pulling themselves out of a game against the Red Sox an hour before first pitch.
This is who Jeter is.
He isn't much of a captain. The Yankees knew this when they agreed
to bring back the iconic shortstop last winter for an over-market
deal. So as long as Jeter isn't planning a rally on Posada's behalf,
- it probably would've been better to ignore Jeter's comments."...
---------------------------------
2/27/09, "
'A Great Day to Surf the (radio) Waves'," Cincinnati.com, Daugherty
We take our baseball broadcasters personally here,
as personally as we take the Reds."...
Columnist Dan DiMauro is a fan of John Sterling and Suzyn Waldman
"
Let me just say this: I don't care whether you like him.
I like him. And Suzyn Waldman, too. So do millions of Yankee fans,
otherwise known as the target audience. Sterling and Waldman are part
of every day from April through October, eccentric, eclectic,
entertaining and everywhere the season takes us....
- The (NY) Times reported that Mushnick "has written more than 270 articles about Sterling," calling him a "narcissistic, condescending blowhard."
Then the best quote of all:
"Yankees fans who like him are people who just want someone to root for the team," Mushnick said.
- Or is more boring than geometry?
And
it's not like Sterling and Waldman never criticize the Yankees. They
do it often. (Just wait till they fail to advance a runner)....
It's OK to enhance the product with some personality, you know.
- John Sterling makes you listen because of what's coming. And what's not.
Like one night this summer.
We're on vacation in Ocean City, N.J., sipping some euphoric nectar
on the porch listening to the ballgame. Sterling is apoplectic that
home plate umpire Jerry Layne is taking too long to call balls and strikes. Suddenly, he breaks into song:
- "Everybody's hand in hand ... waitin' for Jerry Layne."
It's a takeoff on an old Sinatra lyric ("everybody's hand in hand, swingin' down the lane.")
- I'm sorry. But that's perfect, brilliant and the essence of John Sterling.
- And I want him back for as long as he wants to do it.
I believe I speak for Yankees Universe on this.
This is the opinion of Day sports columnist Mike DiMauro."
- --------------------
- More on radio and baseball generally:
8/26/2009, "Radio is what sold me on baseball,"
Hossrex, Dugout Central (I copied this material from Dugout Central in
2009. (The original link is inactive now, so I use the link on my
blog).
Hossrex: "There’s something classic about baseball,
- there’s something classic about radio, and there’s
-----------------
1/7/10, "Roger Clemens will obviously wear a Red Sox cap if he goes in the Hall of Fame," Rob Neyer, ESPN
....................
............
Stumbleupon
StumbleUpon
