3/3/11, Deggans, Poynter, "LeBron James’ The Decision
. Sideline reporter Erin Andrews’ endorsement deal with Reebok. Allegations of foot-dragging in coverage of a lawsuit accusing star quarterback Ben Roethlisberger of sexual assault.
The list of ethical landmines
sports media behemoth ESPN has stepped on are legion, with new entries popping up with regularity. Hardened cynics have suggested mixing the terms “ethics” and “ESPN” might be a bit of an oxymoron – given how many
So it makes a certain
- line-crossing scandals the folks in Bristol, Conn. negotiate every year.
kind of sense that, when ombudsman Don Ohlmeyer’s term wound up, ESPN turned to one of the country’s most-respected journalism institutions to fill the gap: the Poynter Institute for Media Studies (full disclosure: the newspaper where I work, the St. Petersburg Times, is actually owned by the non-profit institute).
But the arrangement
– in which three staffers at the school for journalists will produce monthly columns on ESPN’s ethical issues, starting this month –
Will ESPN transform
- raises an uncomfortable question.
itself ethically with Poynter’s guidance? Or will the Worldwide Leader
John A. Walsh,
- cloak itself in the school’s credibility while largely ignoring its advice?
executive vice president and executive editor at ESPN, almost bristles at the question. “We want to be held accountable,” Walsh said, noting that executives began discussions with Poynter at the end of 2010, before problems with Andrews’ shoe deal hit the news. “We want to be transparent. In this ever-expanding age, we think we can improve ourselves.
At Poynter, president Karen Brown Dunlap
- And if an in-house critic helps us do that, that’s great.”
acknowledged there’s a little bit of faith-taking going on here. Rejecting the notion that the institute will be ESPN’s ombudsman – none of their staff will be based in Bristol, and they won’t be an audience advocate in the traditional way
— Dunlap presented their 18-month Review Project as a way to start an important conversation about journalism values around and inside the sports media giant.
“I keep thinking about the 35-year history of Poynter; we have regularly dealt with companies that have run off the track ethically…(and) I think there is a strong sense they want to be an organization that lives up to what they profess,” she said.
“This is a sports organization
that is deciding on its values,” added Dunlap, noting that Poynter will also deliver additional pieces as news events warrant, using social media to extend the conversation. “If we put out there the values that should be followed – constant
- examples of how people practice values-based journalism –
and they choose not to follow that, it’s their decision. But I believe they want to do the right thing.”
One place to start, is a simple question. Who exactly is a journalist at ESPN?
Walsh said ESPN is working on that issue right now
, standardizing job descriptions and pulling together its ethical policies for various corners of its business into one form (he also noted,
- people who report from the field like Erin Andrews are considered journalists,
- with the attendant ethical requirements).
“ESPN has grown into what it is by making decisions as the company
goes along,” he said, noting it hadn’t pulled all its ethical guidelines into one place until February. ...As technology and media platforms evolve,
So how to deal with a sports media company that has entertainment in the first word of its name, employing both journalists and media personalities
And is it fair to
- journalism is morphing from a craft to an act.
ask someone who only occasionally commits journalism to follow the tighter ethical rules journalists assume?
Now the true scope of Poynter’s challenge emerges. And some critics say the first order of business should be examining a long-standing gripe;
that the channel
Do sports the
- provides more coverage and hype to games and sports teams it is aligned with as a programmer.
Worldwide Leader doesn’t broadcast so much
– say, professional hockey – get less attention from the journalists at ESPN?...
Will Leitch, founding
editor of the sports gossip blog Deadspin and a contributing editor for New York magazine, said ESPN’s ethical reputation is so compromised
that when it pulled a story on LeBron James partying in Las Vegas because the writer didn’t identify himself as a journalist while reporting the story – a major ethical no-no –
- many still saw it as a move to protect a basketball star rather than support ethics.
“It’s telling that ESPN actually did something ethical
and no one believed them,” he said. “It’s one thing for the Washington Post to have an ombudsman…but you don’t see the E! entertainment channel with one.”
Leitch said ESPN employs many journalists who feel frustrated by the company’s ethical breaches and bad reputation. He also criticized a central issue for ESPN; it
often tries to cover sports as an independent entity without acknowledging its own role
- as a major player in the sports world.
If ESPN personalities advocate for a playoff system in college football, is it because the company already broadcasts so many bowl games? And how will ESPN handle news coverage of the University of Texas after the September debut of its new, 24-hour channel featuring Longhorn sports,
developed with the school in
- a deal valued at $300 million over 20 years?
“Their footprint affects everything,” Leitch said. “A lot of ESPN’s stars are bigger brands than the athletes they cover. It started out more as a journalism organization . . .
But Walsh disagreed
- (but) now they’re in the entertainment business.”
with many criticisms leveled against ESPN, defending The Decision by noting that journalist Michael Wilbon interviewed James during the special, calling
- the notion the company might co-opt Poynter’s credibility “preposterous.”
“We’ve had three ombudsmen, we felt some of the matter was
repetitious, why not try something different?” he said. “ESPN always operates on the premise we can be better.”
3/3/11, "Addressing some ethical questions at the "Worldwide Leader,"" National Sports Journalism, Eric Deggans, via Poynter.org/Romenesko
- Eric Deggans is TV and Media Critic for the St. Petersburg Times and a 1990 graduate of the Indiana University School of Journalism."
Labels: Eric Deggans, Ethical questions of ESPN association with Poynter