XM MLB Chat

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Joe Christensen said no to Jeter for 2006 MVP because he's on 'team of rich guys getting it done,' later says is demeaning to suggest he'd be biased

Tues., Sept. 19, 2006, Baseball Beat with Charley Steiner on XM 175, Charley talks with Minneapolis Star-Tribune writer, Joe Christensen about the upcoming AL MVP Awards.

  • Two members of the Twins are in the running and some have mentioned Derek Jeter as a possibility.

Along the conversation, Charley says to him, "Well, I offer you Derek Jeter," and gives a few reasons why.

  • But, Christensen says,

Christensen offers a 2nd reason not to vote for Jeter:
  • He says to Charley,
"Well, they have Mariano Rivera like you said."
  • Christensen a minute ago was ready to put Rivera on a back burner, turns around and uses the guy's presence on the team
  • as a reason not to vote for Jeter.
  • ---------------------------
9 weeks later Christensen claims he's a completely unbiased baseball awards voter and for you to suggest otherwise is "demeaning" to him and a "fallacy." 2006 AL MVP votes have been tallied and Derek Jeter came in #2, Morneau #1. "Is the MVP vote proof of a backlash to what they dismiss as New York hype? In general, baseball writers deserve more credit than that."...
  • Mr. Harper selects Joe Christensen as an example of an awards voter who deserves credit for being honest, free of bias, and in this case, one whose vote would not be influenced by the perception that Jeter mainly gets attention because of the high profile team he plays on. Harper says Christensen finds it "demeaning" and a "fallacy" for anyone to suggest baseball writers would be biased:

"Joe Christensen, who covers the Twins for the Minneapolis Star-Tribune and voted for winner Justin Morneau over Jeter, offers a more reasonable take on the subject. He admits that talk of Jeter being overrated is practically a fact of life in the Midwest,

"I'd be lying to say there's not an anti-Jeter sentiment in the Midwest," Christenson said yesterday. "It's there.

  • that type of feeling

among fans get in the way of their voting for the MVP.""

  • -----------------

Later in the same article Harper seems to back track, says in fact Jeter may have been hurt because he played in a 'star studded lineup' (which Christensen did say 9 weeks earlier is the reason he wouldn't vote for Jeter, but now says it's "demeaning" to suggest he would allow prejudice against a big market team to affect his vote). Harper mentions Jeter picked up the slack when "Matsui, Sheffield and Cano were out with injuries" and Arod was without a big hit for an extended period.

  • Christensen acknowledges the injuries but says there was still 'a ton of talent on that team.'

Harper: "What also hurts Jeter may not be a New York backlash as much as

"You know he's valuable," Christensen said of Jeter, "but even with the injuries the Yankees had,

So not "demeaning" or a "fallacy" after all. Baseball award voters are "ethically grounded." ------------------------- "Curtis Granderson is having a great season for the Yankees, but he's surrounded by talent."...(near end of article). article via BTF

Labels:

Stumbleupon StumbleUpon

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home